Supreme Court Turns Down Chance To Claw Back Abortion Clinic Buffer Zones

Advertisement

The U.S. Supreme Court turned down a chance to change its previous decision that allowed buffer zones around abortion clinics, even though two of the court’s most conservative members were against it.

The court said in two orders that it would not hear challenges to laws in Carbondale, Ill., and Englewood, N.J., that stop anti-abortion activists from “sidewalk counseling” people who are going to an abortion clinic.

Both Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito said they would have taken up the case, but it needed the votes of four justices to be carried out.

Based on the Supreme Court’s decision in Hill v. Colorado in 2000, lower courts upheld the ordinances in both cities. That decision said that a similar law in Colorado did not violate the First Amendment.

Since then, groups against abortion have tried to destroy the precedent. Some conservative justices recently said that the decision was an abuse of free speech, including in the Supreme Court’s opinion overturning constitutional protections for abortion. This gave them more hope.

Advertisement

“Hill has been seriously undermined, if not completely eroded, and our refusal to provide clarity is an abdication of our judicial duty,” Thomas wrote.

“Hill was wrong the day it was decided, and the case for overruling it has only strengthened ever since,” Paul Clement, a veteran conservative Supreme Court attorney who previously served as solicitor general, wrote in the petition challenging Carbondale’s ordinance.

Coalition Life is an anti-abortion group that does “sidewalk counseling” in places like Carbondale. Clement worked for them. To get rid of the 24-year-old rule, the group asked for help from 15 Republican state attorneys general, Alliance Defending Freedom, and other anti-abortion groups.

As it asked the court to reject Coalition Life’s appeal, the city pointed out that its law had been thrown out.

“Petitioner wants to fast-track a request that this Court overturn Hill just as it overturned Roe v. Wade. This Court should deny that request. This case is a far cry from an ideal—or even passable—vehicle for revisiting Hill,” Neal Katyal, another veteran Supreme Court advocate, who served as acting solicitor general under former President Barack Obama, wrote on behalf of the city.

In Englewood, resident Jeryl Turco fought against a similar law that the city passed in 2014 to create a buffer zone around an abortion clinic because of violent protesters from a group called Bread of Life.

 

Advertisement

Related Posts

BREAKING NEWS: Taylor Swift Announces the End of Her Legendary Show, Declares: ‘I’m Moving to Canada and Will Never Return to the U.S., I Don’t Want to Breathe the Same Air as That Jerk.’

Advertisement Taylor Swift, one of the most prominent figures in the global pop music scene, recently astonished fans and the media with a surprising announcement. During a…

MLB Baseball Player’s 3-Word T-Shirt Message Sparks Outrage

Advertisement Manny Machado is no stranger to controversy, and the San Diego Padres third baseman has been called out repeatedly by his fellow MLB stars, both publicly…

KNEELING: University of Texas Withdraws Scholarships from All Students Who Kneel During National Anthem

Advertisement The University of Texas (UT) has recently come under intense scrutiny for reportedly revoking scholarships from five athletes who knelt during the National Anthem to protest…

Maxine Waters Takes Swipe At Melania Trump In Wild Rant

Advertisement Democratic California Representative Maxine Waters called on President Donald Trump to investigate and potentially deport First Lady Melania Trump during an anti-DOGE protest in Los Angeles…

Meet Yazemeenah Rossi, the 69-year-old hailed as the “world’s most beautiful grandmother”

Advertisement Yazemeenah Rossi, often called “the world’s most beautiful grandmother,” proves that age is just a number. Born in 1955 in Corsica, France, she began her modeling…

What does it mean to wear a ring on the right hand?

Advertisement Do you wear a ring on your right hand without thinking? Yet, this simple sign says a lot about you. Why do some people prefer to…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What do you like about this page?

0 / 400